Tuesday, June 9, 2015

Chapter 3 (cont..6) Compression failure in Limit state method

In the previous section we saw the type of beam in which the steel reinforcement yielded before the ultimate state was reached. In this section we are going to discuss another type of beam. This beam has a larger area of steel and/or the steel is of high strength grade. Let us see the various stages before failure:

Stage 1: C and T increases normally to resist the external load. The stresses and strains are in the linear elastic state. This is shown in the fig.3.23 below. The strain in steel at this stage is denoted as εst,1. This is less than ε*st .

In the stage 1, εst,1 < ε*st , because the steel has not yielded. It is in the initial linear elastic state. Also εc,1 the strain in concrete is far less than 0.0035, the ultimate strain. The stress fst,1 in steel is less than 0.87fy . We know that 0.87fy is the design yield stress (fy/1.15 = 0.87fy). That is., the stress corresponding to the strain  ε*st. 

The stress fc,1 in the top most compression fibre is far less than 0.447fck , the ultimate stress in concrete.

We can see that this stage 1 is same as the stage 1 of the previous beam. (fig.3.22 of previous section)

Fig.3.23
Stages before failure of a beam section





Stage 2: As we continue to increase the load, the steel will not yield because now it has a larger area and/or the steel is of high strength grade, and so is stronger. The situation of having 'larger area' can be viewed mathematically as follows: Tensile stress = Tensile force / Area of steel. As the area which is in the denominator has increased, the tensile stress has decreased. So the steel does not yield. The situation of having steel of high strength grade is obvious: As the steel itself is strong, very large force is required to make it yield. In the previous beam, in stage 2, the steel yielded and entered the horizontal flat portion of the stress strain curve . So in it, the steel elongated under constant force. But here, steel has not reached the flat portion.

So when the loading increases, the tensile force in steel also increases. To maintain the equilibrium, the compressive force C has to increase in such a way that C = T. For this, the NA shifts downwards to increase the area of the region under compression, and thus to increase C.

These details can be seen in the fig.3.23 above. In the stage 2, the strain εst,2 in steel is still less than ε*st . So the steel has not yielded. The NA has shifted downwards. The strain εc,2 in the top most compression fibre is still less than 0.0035.

The stress fst,2 in steel is less than the design yield strength of 0.87fy, indicating that the stress is still capable of increasing. The stress in concrete fc,2 is less than 0.447fck.

So the section manages to resist the increased external bending moment by shifting the NA downwards. But as part of the experiment, we are increasing the load further. So the beam moves on to the next stage.

Stage 3: We are increasing the load further. During this increase also, the steel does not yield. It continues to increase the T in it. C also has to increase. The increase in area of concrete (by shifting the NA downwards) becomes insufficient to take this higher C. So the stress in it will increase and so will the strain. The strain will reach the ultimate value of 0.0035. Thus the impending state of failure is reached. With any more increase in load, the concrete will fail by crushing. At this point also, the steel is safe.

In the previous beam also, the failure was by crushing of concrete. But there is an important difference. In the present beam, the steel has not yielded. So there was no deflection for the beam and there were no wider cracks. So there was no warning about failure. This type of failure occurs suddenly and is called compression failure.

The details of stage 3 are shown in the fig.3.23 above. In the stage 3, the strain εst,3 in steel is still less than ε*st . That is., the steel is showing no sign of yielding. The NA has shifted further downwards. The strain εc,3 in the top most compression fibre has reached 0.0035, which is the ultimate strain.

The stress fst,3 in steel is still less than 0.87fy. The stress in concrete fc,3 has reached 0.447fck.

It may be noted that in the above experiment on the second beam, we say that the beam has reached the ultimate state (the state of impending failure), when the strain in the top most compression fibre reached 0.0035. At this point, the steel is nowhere near the point of yielding. But as the concrete has reached the ultimate state, the beam as a whole has reached the ultimate state.

The beam shown in fig.3.20 of the previous section is an example of this type of beam. In it, the stress and strain at the ultimate state is in the blue colored curved region.


Thus we now know the reason why, at the ultimate state, different values are possible for the stress in steel, while that in the extreme concrete fibre remain fixed at 0.447fck.

Now we can discuss a point about attaching the stress-strain curve of steel in the beam sections. We have seen that we just need one single stress value from the stress-strain curve of steel: That which corresponds to the centroid. Any other point on the curve is irrelevant to a particular problem. So the curve is usually not shown in the analysis diagrams. Instead, an arrow is shown at the level of the centroid to indicate the stress. But we have to attach the stress-strain curve of concrete because it's dimensions like total depth, depth of rectangular portion etc., has to be calculated for the determination of compressive forces. An example is shown in the fig.3.24 below:

Fig.3.24

Stresses and strains at ultimate state





We can say that the beam in the first experiment above has a particular combination of steel: 
A combination of:

• a particular grade of steel fy,1 (Fe250, 415 or 500.) and 
• area of steel Ast,1 . 

Similarly, the beam in the second experiment has a combination of fy,2 and Ast,2. The cross sectional dimensions: depth and width, of both the beams are the same.

Combination 1 is such that at ultimate state, the steel would have yielded. That is., during the loading process, the steel yields first, and as the loading is continued, the top most compression fibre reaches the ultimate state. Such a beam is called an 'Under reinforced beam'.

Combination 2 is such that at ultimate state, the steel would not have yielded. That is., during the loading process, the top most compression fibre reaches the ultimate state first. The steel will still be in the elastic state. There is no point in thinking about what will happen to steel if we continue loading after this ultimate state. This is because even though the steel is still safe, the 'beam as a whole' will cease to serve it's purpose when the top most compression fibre reaches the ultimate state. Such a beam is called an 'Over reinforced beam'. 

So in both Under reinforced and Over reinforced beams, the strain of 0.0035 and a stress of 0.447fck in the top most concrete compression fibre is the criterion for Ultimate state.

In the above definitions for Under reinforced and Over reinforced sections, that of the Over reinforced section is more 'direct'. Because, the criterion for ultimate state is related to concrete, and in the Over reinforced section, that concrete reaches the ultimate state, while steel is still safe. But in the case of Under reinforced section, the criterion for ultimate state will occur only after the yielding of steel.

So one may think that the loading can be continued even after the yielding of steel because the concrete is still safe. But this is not the case. The attainment of ultimate state in the concrete is related to the quantity of steel that is provided. This can be proved as follows:

We have seen that when the steel yields at constant stress, the NA moves upwards to increase the lever arm z. (fig.3.22) Lesser area of steel means that the steel yields at lower loads, and so the NA will also move upwards at these lower loads. So the area of concrete available becomes less, and thus it will reach the ultimate state even at lower loads.


So we cannot say that if low quantity of steel is provided, the steel will become unsafe at lower loads, and concrete will remain safe. The fact is that at low quantity steel, concrete will reach ultimate state at lower loads. However, we must remember that when we design a new beam, all provisions of the various relevant codes should be satisfied, and lower quantities of steel than required should not be permitted.

We can do some mathematical derivations by which, we will be able to say whether a beam section given to us is Under reinforced or Over reinforced. For this purpose, we fix up an 'ideal' combination which falls between the above two combinations. This combination is such that during the loading, the attainment of ultimate state in the topmost compression fibre and the yielding of steel happens simultaneously. Such a section is called a 'Balanced section'. In the next section we will analyze a balanced section. After that analysis, we will be able to mathematically define under reinforced and over reinforced sections. 

Previous

Next
                                                         
            Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com- All Rights Reserved


Monday, June 8, 2015

Chapter 3 (cont..5) Tension failure in Limit state method

In the previous section we have seen that fst can take different values. To explain this behaviour, we will discuss about the stages that lead to the failure of a beam section.

Consider a beam being loaded. When the load increases, the stresses in concrete and steel also increase. The internal moment which resist the applied external bending moment is given by Force x Lever arm. This is shown in the fig. below:

Fig.3.21
Internal moment at the beam section


Compressive force or tensile force multiplied by the lever arm gives the internal moment developed at the section



The force that we use for computation of the internal moment can be the compressive force C in concrete or the tensile force T in steel. Both will give the same result. So we can write:

Internal moment developed = T x z = C x z

z is the lever arm, which is the distance between the point of application of C and T. C acts at the centroid of the concrete stress block and T acts at the centroid of steel.

Let us now see the different stages that the beam section will pass through, while it is being loaded to the ultimate state:

Stage 1: C and T increases normally to resist the external load. The stresses and strains are in the linear elastic state. This is shown in the fig.3.22 below. The strain in steel at this stage is denoted as εst,1. This is less than ε*st .

Here ε*st is the 'quantity of strain' which when obtained, confirmation can be made that the steel has yielded. This is the last point of the curved portion, which is obtained by drawing the dashed parallel line through 0.002 strain. (The last row in the table for Fe415 and Fe500) So we can write:


Eq.3.12



   

In the stage 1, εst,1 < ε*st , because the steel has not yielded. It is in the initial linear elastic state. Also εc,1 the strain in concrete is far less than 0.0035, the ultimate strain. The stress fst,1 in steel is less than 0.87fy . We know that 0.87fy is the design yield stress (fy/1.15 = 0.87fy). That is., the stress corresponding to the strain  ε*st. 

The stress fc,1 in the top most compression fibre is far less than 0.447fck , the ultimate stress in concrete.  

Fig.3.22
Stages before failure of beam section


The beam section passes through linear state and non linear state before failure

Stage 2: The steel enters the non-linear stage and has begun to yield. But once the steel has yielded, it will continue to elongate at constant stress. That is., the strain will increase at constant stress. (The final horizontal line of the stress-strain curve).  As the stress in steel is constant, the force T in it is also constant. But as the external load is being increased, the applied bending- moment is also increasing.

As T is remaining constant, the resisting internal moment can be increased only by increasing z. 'z' is the distance between the centroid of concrete stress block and the centroid of steel. The centroid of steel cannot change as it is held in position. But centroid of concrete stress block can change. For this, the effective concrete area taking part in the compression should decrease. For this, the NA should move upwards. Then, the total height of the concrete stress block will decrease, and it's centroid will move upwards. When this happens, the lever-arm z will increase.

These details can be seen in the fig.3.22 above. In the stage 2, the strain εst,2 in steel has become equal to ε*st . So the steel has yielded. The NA has shifted upwards. The strain εc,2 in the top most compression fibre is still less than 0.0035.

The stress fst,2 in steel is at the constant value of 0.87fy. The stress in concrete fc,2 is less than 0.447fck.

So even though the steel has yielded, the section manages to resist the external bending-moment by increasing z. But as part of the experiment, we are increasing the load further. So the beam moves on to the next stage.

Stage 3: The reduced area of concrete has to take more load now. As a result, stress in it begins to increase. The strain also increase. But the concrete cannot take large strains as in the case of steel. 

We have seen the difference in the strain values of concrete and steel (fig.2.15) when we discussed the working stress method. Here also in the limit state method, this difference in strains has much significance. So we will write it down again:

The reinforcing steel have a greater ductility. It can undergo greater strains than concrete. Yielding of steel occurs at higher stresses, and the amount of yield, which is measured as strain can be in the range 0.12 to 0.20, before failure of steel occur. But for concrete, this range is 0.003 to 0.0045. To get a better understanding of these ranges, we can think of two specimens, one of concrete and the other of steel. Let both of them have the same length of say 20 cm, then the maximum increase in length that the steel specimen can have is calculated as follows:

Strain =  Δl / l = 0.12 to 0.20. So Δl = 0.12 x 20 to 0.2 x 20cm = 2.4 to 4.0cm

Similarly, the decrease in length that the concrete specimen can have is calculated as follows:

Strain =  Δl / l = 0.003 to 0.0045. So Δl = 0.003 x 20 to 0.0045 x 20cm = 0.06 to 0.09cm

From the above, we can see that, when concrete and steel are combined to form a composite material, at higher stresses, the concrete will fail before failure of steel occurs. This happens in our beam also: The load is being increased even after the yielding of steel has occured. Concrete cannot take this large strain, and it will soon reach the ultimate strain of 0.0035, and will fail by crushing.

But before this failure of concrete occur, the steel has yielded to a greater extent. This cause the beam to deflect more and the cracks at the bottom side of the beam become wider. Such deflections and wider cracks give sufficient warning about the beam failure that is about to take place.

So the failure of the beam is by the crushing of concrete. But it was initiated by the yielding of steel under tension. This type of failure is called tension failure.

The details of stage 3 are shown in the fig.3.22 above In the stage 3, the strain εst,3 in steel has become greater than ε*st . This is because the steel is elongating at constant stress. The NA has shifted further upwards. The strain εc,3 in the top most compression fibre has reached 0.0035, which is the ultimate strain.

The stress fst,3 in steel is at the constant value of 0.87fy. The stress in concrete fc,3 has reached 0.447fck.

It may be noted that in the above experiment, we say that the beam has reached the ultimate state (the state of impending failure), when the strain in the top most compression fibre reached 0.0035. The steel began to yield long before this strain was obtained in concrete. But yielding of steel cannot be taken as a criterion for reaching the ultimate state. Because, as stated earlier, steel can continue to perform through larger strains. The concrete cannot go through these larger strains and so will fail before steel. The beam will serve it's purpose only if both steel and concrete are performing satisfactorily at all the sections. But here concrete has reached it's ultimate state. So the beam as a whole has reached it's ultimate state. Thus strain value of 0.0035 in the extreme compression fibre of concrete is taken as the criterion for deciding whether the beam has reached ultimate state or not.      

The beam shown in fig.3.19 of the previous section is an example of this type of beam. In it, the stress and strain in steel at the ultimate state is in the magenta colored straight line region. So the steel has yielded.

Suppose in the experiment, the beam that we used, has a larger area of steel and/or the steel is of high strength grade, then the results would be different. In the next section we will see the details of such a beam.


PREVIOUS

NEXT


                                                         
            Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved

Sunday, June 7, 2015

Chapter 3 (cont..4) Stresses in steel at Ultimate state

In the previous section we saw the details of the design curves. We also saw the tables. Now we will see in detail, how the design curves are used in the analysis.

Before we proceed with our discussion, let us try to understand the variation of stresses across a beam section. The fig.3.17 below gives the details:

Fig.3.17
Variation of stresses across the section


The stresses at a beam section varies in the vertical direction only. There is no variation in the horizontal direction.


We know that the stress varies only in the vertical direction. So the stress in any fibre will be different from the stress in the fibres above and below it. (However, In the regions near the top of the section, where the strain has exceeded 0.002, the stress will have a constant value of 0.447fck). There will be no variation in the horizontal direction. So all the fibres in any one horizontal layer will experience the same stress. We have already seen the details of the stress-strain curve which give variation in concrete (fig.21 of the code). We saw (fig.3.4) how it is attached to a beam section. In a similar way, the stress-strain curve of steel can also be attached to the beam section as shown in fig.3.18 below:

Fig.3.18
Stress-strain curve of steel attached to the beam section.




In the above fig., the origin (0,0) of the curve for steel is placed at the NA. From there the tensile stress and strain increase as we move downwards. But below the NA, the major portion consists of cracked concrete. This cracked concrete does not take any tension. Even if it does take any tension, the curve is not applicable because the curve is prepared for tension in steel only. But we have steel further down, near the bottom edge of the section. The curve is applicable there. We can find the strain in the steel, and from that, calculate the stress from the curve.

We have seen that the strain variation can be represented by a straight line because plane sections remain plane after bending. (We discussed this based on figs.3.6,3.7 and 3.8.) So we can easily calculate the strain in the steel. This is shown in the fig.3.19 below:

Fig.3.19
Strain values in steel


Strain in the top fibre of steel is different from the strain in bottom fibre



In the above fig., PQ is the straight line which represents the strain. As PQ is straight, using similar triangles, we can calculate the strain in any fibre, if we know the distance of that fibre from the NA. The strain at the topmost fibre of steel will be less than that in the bottom most fibre. So the stresses at these points will also be different. But as the area of steel is small, we can take the strain at the centroid of steel. This strain at the centroid is denoted as εst . The stress corresponding to this strain value at the centroid is calculated from the stress-strain curve. This stress value is denoted as fst . And this stress is assumed to be acting uniformly on the entire area of steel. If there are more than one layer of bars, the centroid of the 'bar group' should be considered.

Note that the strain in steel εst , that we obtain from the line PQ in the above fig. is the strain at the ultimate state. This is clear from the fact that the strain at the top most compression fibre is marked as 0.0035.

So now we know how to calculate fst, the stress in steel at the ultimate state. Let us examine the different values of fst that can possibly occur in the steel at the ultimate state. In the above fig., the horizontal dashed line from the centroid of the bar meets the stress-strain curve at the magenta line. This is the final horizontal region of the stress-strain curve. In this case, we can easily calculate fst because, there is only one value of stress in this region, and this value is the design yield strength (fy/1.15 = 0.87fy) of steel. We get this value when the strain εst in steel is equal to or greater than the yield strain: 0.00380 if it is Fe415 (Table for Fe415) and 0.00417 if it is Fe500 (Table for Fe500) . That is., when the steel has yielded. Now consider the fig.3.20 below:

Fig.3.20
Strain value falls in the curved region


When the steel has not yielded, the stress and strain values fall within the curved or transition region


The horizontal dashed line meets the design stress-strain curve at the blue curve. This means that the steel has not yielded. This happens when either the steel used is of very high strength, and/or, the steel has a larger area so that it is more strong and does not yield even when the concrete in the portion above NA has reached the ultimate state.

In the next section, we will see the explanation for the different values of stresses.


PREVIOUS

NEXT

   
            Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved