Thursday, March 19, 2015

Chapter 16 (cont..17) Design of Open well staircase

In this section we will discuss the analysis and design of an 'Open well stair'. In this type of stairs, the flights and landings used for climbing, are given near the outer walls of a stair case room. This will create a 'well-like' portion near the middle of the room. The figs.16.102,103 and 104 below shows the plans and sections of an open-well stair.
Fig.102
Key plan showing position of beams, columns and the staircase
Key plan showing position of beams, columns and the open well staircase

Fig.103
Section XX

Fig.104
Section YY
Detailed sectional view of an open well staicase
In the above figs., the method of naming of beams and columns is as specified in SP34. For example: COL 2 Q2 is the column Q2 in FLOOR 2.
From the key plan, we can see that in each floor, there are three flights. AB, BC and CD. In Floor1. the flight AB rests on the ground at A and on an inclined beam at B. This inclined beam (denoted as St,B) is supported on Col Q1 and Q2. Flight BC is supported on masonry walls at B and C. Though not related to our present stair design problem, lintel beams should be provided in all the masonry walls as shown in the section YY. In this building, the height at which landing C is embedded in the masonry wall coincides with the position of the Lintel beam.  Flight CD is supported on the inclined beam St,B at C and on beam Bm4 at D. The same arrangement is provided in Floor 2 also. The only difference is that the flight AB starts from the beam. The part views of the building can be seen in the slide show below:

We will do the analysis and design of the three flights in Floor2. For this first we will draw the line diagram of each flight showing the effective spans. This is given in the fig.105 below:
Fig.105
Effective span of flights
From the fig.105, we can see that AB and CD have the same effective span,and has the largest value of 4.17m. So we will use this value to fix up the preliminary value of 't', the thickness of waist slab. For all the previous problems on longitudinal stairs, we used the thumb rule of t = l /20 to fix up a preliminary value. Now we will see a different method:
From the previous examples, we have seen that, a lower value of thickness may be sufficient to resist the bending moment, but that lower value will not satisfy the deflection check. That is., the deflection criterion is more important than the bending moment criterion, when finalising the thickness of the slab. So we will do the procedure for deflection check in a sort of 'reverse' manner to fix up a preliminary value for 't'. This can be done as follows:
We know that, for spans less than 10m, to satisfy the deflection check, the following condition should be satisfied: (Details here)
l_d_pro_1   - - - - (1)
For simply supported members, (l/d) basic = 20.
Now we take kt. This can be calculated by using the expression given in SP24:
kt_1  - - - - (2)
where
fs_1    - - - - (3)
But in the above expressions, there are three unknowns. (a) pt, (b) Area of steel required, and (c) Area of steel provided. These three unknowns can be solved by making two simple assumptions.
First we assume the Area of steel provided for a 1m wide strip with total depth t = 200mm. If the concrete cover  is 20mm, and 12mm (Fe 415) bars are provided, effective depth d = 200 –20 –6 = 174mm:
Assume that 12 mm bars are provided at a spacing of 150mm c/c. So we can make the bar area calculations (Details here):
Ab_1
=113.1 mm2
Ast_1
= 754 mm2  - - - - (4)
So pt = (Ast x 100) / (b d) = (754 x100)/(1000 x174) = 0.43% - - - - (5)
So we can say that the pt for a stair will have a value around 0.43%. It may be noted that 0.43% is only an approximate value. In some stairs it can go up to 0.50% or even more. But the next time we do a problem of longitudinal stairs, we can straight away assume pt  = 0.43%. There is no need to assume a section and the steel provided, and do the area calculations above.
However, this is only for preliminary dimensions.  The dimensions so obtained should be finalised only after detailed checks using the actual value of steel required and steel provided.
Now we assume that the Area of steel required is same as the Area of steel provided = 754 mm2 
So fs will become 0.58 x fy = 0.58 x415 = 240.7 - - - - (6)
Substituting (5) and (6) in (2), we get kt = 1.3 - - - - (7)
Substituting (7) in (1) we get (l/d) provided should be less than or equal to 20 x 1.3 = 26
In our present problem, l = 4170mm
So 4170 /d ≤ 26
So d should be greater than or equal to 4170/26 = 160.4 mm
If d is to be greater than 160.4mm, t should be greater than 160.4 +6 +20 = 186.4mm - - - - (8)
If we use the thumb rule we will get total depth t = 4170/20 = 208.5mm - - - - (9)
Let us adopt the value in (8) and provide t = 190mm.
However, as mentioned above, the design using this value of 190mm should be finalized only after the checks using actual area of steel required and the actual area of steel provided.
For a uniform appearance, we can provide the same t for flight BC also. Thus, the load per 1m2 area will be same on all the flights. We will see the load calculation details in the next section.

PREVIOUS      CONTENTS      NEXT
             Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved

Friday, March 13, 2015

Chapter 16 (cont..16)

The following solved example illustrates the design of a typical structurally independent tread slab of a stair
The reinforcement details according to the above solved example is shown in the fig.16.97 below:
Fig.16.97
Reinforcement details
Reinforcement details of a typical structurally independent tread slab of a stair.
We will now discuss about the above fig.
In cantilever members, the main tensile steel is given at the top. So in our case, the main bars are given as the top most layer. The distributor bars are given as the second layer from the top. This arrangement will give maximum possible effective depth ‘d’ for the section.
The 10 mm dia. main bars at the top should be given sufficient anchorage. This is obtained by giving a standard 90o bend, and extending each of them into the wall. The length of this extension from the face of the wall should be determined:
Details about development length can be seen here: unique value of Ld
(a) The 10mm dia. bar that we are considering is mild steel and so they are not deformed
(b) The bar is in tension
(c) The grade of concrete is M20
From (c) above, we get  τ bd  = 1.2 N/mm2. From (a), the bar is not deformed. So we cannot increase this τ bd  by 60%. Substituting the values in Eq.14.6 we get Ld  = 453 mm. So each of the 10 mm dia. main bars at the top should be given an extension which is not less than 453 mm.
As the slab has a thickness of 100 mm, a bottom layer consisting of 3 Nos. of 8 mm mild steel bars should be given. This is indicated by the green bars at the bottom layer in section XX. These 3 bars should be given two 90 degree bends at the free end. This is for tying them with the top layer. Distributor bars for this layer consists of 5 Nos. of 6mm mild steel bars. These 3 bars at the bottom most layer also take up loads when stress reversal occurs when the slab is subjected to seismic loads. So these bars should also be given extension into the wall.
In this type of stairs with independent tread slabs, a vertical gap will be present between adjacent slabs. It is recommended that this gap should be filled up with materials of low density such as Light weight concrete, before applying cement plaster or laying tiles. This filling is done in the overlapping 10cm. So the ‘Tread’ of the slabs will not be reduced. This is shown in the fig.16.98 below. As this is done before the finishing works, the use of a different material for the filling will not be visible afterwards.
Fig.16.98
Filling of the vertical gap
Filling of the vertical gaps in structurally independent tread slabs of stairs 

Structurally independent tread slabs simply supported at ends


Fig.16.99
Part view of a stair
This is a transverse stair with independent tread slabs simply supported on masonry walls on either side of the stair.
The above fig. shows the part view of a stair. It consists of independent tread slabs. These slabs are simply supported on masonry walls on either sides of the stair. This type of stair is used only for climbing small heights of about 45 cm to 100 cm. This is because, for climbing higher, the walls on either side will have to be built higher. When climbing higher, the length of stair and the walls will also increase, and this will lead to loss of space under the stair.
The Rise, Tread, and other details are same as that we saw earlier in fig.16.90 in a previous section
The design of a typical tread slab of this type of stair is easier than that of a cantilevering tread slab because alternate Live loads need not be considered. But all other load calculation procedure are the same.
So the three items that constitute the load on 1m length of the tread slab are given by Eq.16.26, 27 and 28. Thus we can write:
Eq.16.34
The load per meter length of a tread slab simply supported on walls = w1 = Eq.16.26 +27 +28
When w1 is determined, we can draw the line diagram as shown below:
Fig.16.100
Line diagram for analysis
From this, we will get the maximum Bending moment at the midspan, and the design of reinforcement can be done. For preliminary proportioning, a thickness of 80mm can be assumed for span upto 1m.
The following Solved example illustrates the design of a typical structurally independent tread slab supported on masonry walls on either side of the stair.
The reinforcement details according to the above solved example is shown in the fig.16.97 below:
Fig.16.101
Reinforcement details
Reinforcement details of a typical structurally independent tread slab resting on masonry walls on either side of the stairs
In the above fig., we can see that the main bars are given in the bottom most layer. They are given a 90o bend at both ends. This bend give better anchorage for the bars.
It may be noted that in this type of stairs also, it is better to fill up the vertical gap between adjacent tread slabs, as we saw earlier in fig.16.98 above.
We have seen the commonly used types of stairs in the above discussions. Before moving to the next chapter, which is about Two way slabs, we will discuss about the design of a ‘Open well staircase’ in the next two sections.

PREVIOUS      CONTENTS      NEXT

              Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved

Wednesday, March 11, 2015

Chapter 16 (cont..15)

For doing the analysis and design, we must first calculate the loads acting on any one slab. For slabs, we usually take the load on 1 m2 area, and when we consider a strip of 1m width, this will be the load per meter length of the strip. But in our present case, we cannot take a 1m wide strip because the width ‘B’ of the tread slab is less than 1m. The area on which the load is to be calculated is shown in green colour in the fig.16.91 given below:
Fig.16.91
Plan showing area of the slab on which load is taken
Plan of a structurally independent tread slab, showing the area on which load is calculated for the analysis and design.
Self wt. of tread slab:
The area of the green coloured portion = 1 x B = B m2
Thickness perpendicular to the plane of the paper = 't'm
So volume = Bt m3
Unit wt. of RCC = 25 KN/m3
Thus wt. of the green coloured portion = 25Bt kN
This is the self wt. on 1m length of the slab.
So we can write:

Eq.16.26
Self wt. of tread slab = 25Bt kN/m
Wt. of finishes:
This is obtained from the codes or data books. It is specified as load per 1m2 of horizontal area. But we are having an area, which though is horizontal, have a lesser value (1 x B m2= Bm2) than 1m2. So we have to modify the value that we obtain from the code or data book, by multiplying it with the actual area that we have. So, if we denote the value obtained from the data book as wf,data then we can write:

Eq.16.27
Wt of finishes = wf,data x B kN/m
Live load:
This is also obtained from the codes or data books. It is specified as load per 1m2 of horizontal area. But we are having an area, which though is horizontal, have a lesser value than 1m2. In the case of LL, the area that we have is still lesser than B m2 because the LL will not be applied on the overlapping area. This is shown in the fig.16.92 below:
Fig.16.92
Lesser area on which LL act
Thus the area that we have is T m2. So we modify the value that we obtain from the code or data book, by multiplying it with the actual area that we have. If we denote the value obtained from the data book as wLL,data then we can write:
Eq.16.28
LL = wLL,data x T kN/m
If we sum up the above three items, we will get the total load acting per 1m length of the slab. But we have to do one more step in this type of stairs. We have to consider another type of LL as specified by the loading code. Accordingly, each tread slab should be capable to resist a concentrated load of 1.3 kN acting at the free end as shown in the fig. below:
Fig.16.93
Concentrated load at the end of cantilever
Each cantilever tread slab should be able to withstand a concentrated load of 1.3 kilo newton applied at the free end of the cantilever.
These two Live loads can be considered separately. That is., we can assume that they do not act at the same time. So we have to consider two possible line diagrams as shown in the figs. below:
Fig.16.94
Uniformly distributed DL and LL
Uniformly distributed DL and LL
Fig.16.95
Uniformly distributed DL and concentrated LL
stair_in_line_diagram2
Out of the above two cases, the one which gives the maximum bending moment at the support must be considered for analysis and design.
The expression for calculating the bending moment caused by a concentrated load is different from that for a UDL.
BM at the support of a cantilever due to UDL = w l2 /2
BM at the support of a cantilever due to concentrated load at free end = Wl
So we have to consider these loads separately. The procedure can be summarized as follows:
First we calculate the BM due to the self weights (DL) based on Eqs. 16.26 and 27
t_in_m_1
Multiplying this by the Load factor, we will get the factored BM. So  we can write:
This is a final quantity, and will not change because we are not considering any other types of DL.
Now we calculate the BM due to the usual LL based on Eq.16.28. We will call it as ‘type I’ LL.
t_in_mLL_1
Multiplying this by the Load factor, we will get the factored BM. So  we can write:
Eq.16.30:
t_in_mLL_2
Next we calculate the BM due to the concentrated LL. We will call it as ‘type II’ LL.
t_in_mLL_type_2_1
Multiplying this by the Load factor, we will get the factored BM. So  we can write:
Eq.16.31:
t_in_mLL_type_2_2
Next we add the two LL moments  to the DL moment separately, to get the two possible Bending moments that can occur. So we can write:
Sum1= Mu,DL  + Mu,LL,I  
Sum2= Mu,DL  + Mu,LL,II   
Out of the above two sums, the largest one is our required value.
The above steps can be represented by a simple flow chart as shown below:
Fig.16.96
Flow chart for final Bending moment
Flow chart for final Bending moment

Thus we get the final factored bending moment, which can be used for the design.
In a similar way, the shear force at the support can also be calculated. The two possible alternative Live loads should be considered, and the one which gives the maximum effect should be taken for the design. For a cantilever member, the reaction at the support is simply equal to the total load on the member. So we can write:
Sum1= (wu,DL  + wu,LL,I ) l
Sum2= (wu,DL  ) l+ wu,LL,II 
Out of the above two sums, the largest one is our required value.
In the above equation,
wu,DL = Load factor x (25t + wf,Data)B Based on Eq.16.26 and 27
wu,LL,I = Load factor x (wLL,Data)T Based on Eq.16.28

wu,LL,II = Load factor x 1.3 Based on Fig.16.93
So we are now in a position to design a typical tread slab of this type of stair.
For preliminary proportioning of the slab, value of ‘t’ can be assumed to be approximately equal to l /10. But it should be finalized only after the required checks.
In the next section, we will see a solved example based on the above discussion.

PREVIOUS      CONTENTS      NEXT

             Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved