Friday, June 5, 2015

Chapter 3 (cont..3) Stress-Strain curve for steel

In the previous section we calculated the last point of the curved portion. In this section, we will calculate the second last point.

We can see a dashed line parallel to the initial inclined line, starting from 0.001 on the X axis. It meets the characteristic curve at a certain point. A horizontal dashed line is drawn from this meeting point towards the left up to the Y axis. At the point of intersection of the horizontal dashed line and the Y axis is marked: '0.975fy'. This means that the 'y coordinate of the point of intersection' of the inclined dashed line with the characteristic curve is 0.975fy. So the y coordinate of the corresponding point on the design curve will be equal to 0.975fy/1.15 = (0.975 x 415)/1.15 = 351.8 N/mm2. Now we want the x coordinate. For this we will use the fig.3.14 given below:

Fig.3.14
Second last point of the curved portion


stress strain curve for cold worked steel has no definite yield point


A triangle P'Q'R' is drawn. P'R' corresponds to the inclined dashed line in the code, drawn from the strain value of 0.001. So we can see that the x coordinate will be equal to 0.001 + P'Q'. Thus our next step is to calculate P'Q'.

In the ΔP'Q'R', tan∠R'P'Q' = R'Q'⁄P'Q'  
⇒ P'Q' = R'Q'⁄tan∠R'P'Q'    

But tan∠R'P'Q' is the slope of P'R'. So it is also the slope of the initial inclined line of the design curve. 

But the slope of this initial inclined line = 
Stress⁄Strain   = Elastic modulus of steel = Es = 2 x 105 N/mm2.

We know that R'Q' = the y coordinate of the point R', which we already calculated as 351.8

Thus we get P'Q' = 351.8⁄200000 = 0.001759

So the x coordinate of point R = 0.001 + 0.001759 = 0.002759 = 0.00276

Thus the coordinates of the second last point of the curved portion are (0.00276, 351.8)

As before, for the general case, for the second last point of the curved portion, we can write the following:

Eq.3.10

x coordinate = 0.001 + [(0.975fy)/ (1.15 x 200000)] = 0.001 + 0.975fy/230000

y coordinate = 0.975fy/ 1.15

So on a new empty graph paper, on which we marked the last point earlier, we can mark the second last point also directly using Eq.3.10. This is shown in the animation below:



In this way, we can calculate the coordinates of the remaining points on the curved portion. We will do one more calculation, but this time for the first point of the curved portion.

For this point, there is no dashed line. This is because, we are now looking at the first point of the curved portion., that is., the first point of transition, which will be on the initial inclined line. We can see that there are 5 inclined dashed lines and 6 horizontal dashed lines. So for the present case, we can use the initial inclined line itself. 

The bottom most horizontal dashed line has a marking of 0.8fy. So the y coordinate is 0.8fy. So we get the y coordinate of the corresponding point on the design curve as 0.8fy/1.15 = (0.8 x 415)/1.15 = 288.7 N/mm2. Now we want the x coordinate. For this we will use the fig.3.15 given below:

Fig.3.15
First point of the curved portion




A triangle P''Q''R'' is drawn. P''R'' corresponds to the initial inclined portion. P'' coincides with the origin. We can see that the x coordinate will be equal to P''Q''. Thus our next step is to calculate P''Q''.

In the ΔP''Q''R'', tan∠R''P''Q'' = R''Q''⁄P''Q''  
⇒ P''Q'' = R''Q''⁄tan∠R''P''Q''    

But tan∠R''P''Q'' is the slope of P''R''. So it is also the slope of the initial inclined line of the design curve. 

But the slope of this initial inclined line = 
Stress⁄Strain   = Elastic modulus of steel = Es = 2 x 105 N/mm2.

We know that R''Q'' = the y coordinate of the point R'', which we already calculated as 288.7

Thus we get P''Q'' = 288.7⁄200000 = 0.0014435

So the x coordinate of point R'' = 0.0014435 = 0.00144

Thus the coordinates of the first point of the curved portion are (0.00144, 288.7)

As before, for the general case, for the first point of the curved portion, we can write the following:

Eq.3.11

x coordinate =  (0.8fy)/ (1.15 x 200000)] = 0.8fy/230000

y coordinate = 0.8fy/ 1.15

So now we have the first point of the curved portion. This is also the last point of the initial straight portion. So we have two points on the initial portion: First is the origin (0,0), and the second is the first point of the curved portion, which we calculated just now. We can draw a line between these two points and thus obtain the initial portion.

Thus we have all the details required to make a complete design curve. As mentioned earlier, when we calculate the details for the intermediate curved portion, we will get the details for the initial and final portions automatically. We can make separate tables giving all the coordinates of the design curve for Fe415 and Fe500 steel.

Strain Stress (N/mm2) Calculation of Strain Calculation of Stress
0.000 0.00
0.00144 288.7 (415x0.80)/230000 (415 x 0.80)/1.15
0.00163 306.7 0.0001+[(415x0.85)/230000] (415 x 0.85)/1.15
0.00192 324.8 0.0003+[(415x0.90)/230000] (415 x 0.90)/1.15
0.00241 342.8 0.0007+[(415x0.95)/230000] (415 x 0.95)/1.15
0.00276 351.8 0.001+[(415x0.975)/230000] (415 x 0.975)/1.15
≥ 0.00380 360.9 0.002+[(415x1.0)/230000] (415 x 1.00)/1.15
Table for Fe500:
Strain Stress (N/mm2) Calculation of Strain Calculation of Stress
0.000 0.00
0.00174 347.8 (500x0.80)/230000 (500 x 0.80)/1.15
0.00195 369.6 0.0001+[(500x0.85)/230000] (500 x 0.85)/1.15
0.00226 391.3 0.0003+[(500x0.90)/230000] (500 x 0.90)/1.15
0.00277 413.0 0.0007+[(500x0.95)/230000] (500 x 0.95)/1.15
0.00312 423.9 0.001+[(500x0.975)/230000] (500 x 0.975)/1.15
≥ 0.00417 434.8 0.002+[(500x1.0)/230000] (500 x 1.00)/1.15
In the above tables, 
• The first row is the origin point (0,0). 
• The second row is the last point of the initial straight portion, which is also the first point of the intermediate curved portion. 
• The last row is the last point of the intermediate curved portion, which is also the first point of the final horizontal portion. A '≥' is given to the strain value. In this, the '=' part indicates the exact point. The '>' part indicates the strain values to the right of the point. For all those points to the right, the stress remains constant, giving a horizontal line.
Now we will have a quick look at the application of these curves: The main application of the design curve is to find the stress corresponding to any strain value. That is., during an analysis process, we may find that the steel reinforcement is strained to a particular value, and we will want to find the stress in that steel. In such a situation, we make use of the design curve. If the strain value fall in the initial or final straight portions, the calculation of stress is easy. But if it falls in the curved portion, then we will have to use linear interpolation. These regions are shown in the fig.3.16 below:

Fig.3.16
Strains in the three regions


strain in steel may fall in any of the three regions: initial straight line, intermediate curved, or final horizontal regions


We have seen that the table of each steel will give complete details (including that of the straight portions) of the design curve. So we don't need to draw the design curve. If the table is available, stress corresponding to any strain value can be calculated.

In the next section, we will have a detailed discussion on the role played by the design curves in the analysis of a beam section.

                                                         
            Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved

Chapter 3 (cont..2) Compressive force contributed by parabolic portion

In the previous section we derived the complete details about the rectangular portion. In this section we will see the parabolic portion. The parabolic portion has an area of 0.447fck (8/21)xu (see derivation here). This area multiplied by the width 'b' of the section will give the volume of the parabolic stress block. And this volume is the compressive force C2 contributed by the parabolic portion. So we get


Eq.3.4
C2 = 0.447fck b (8/21)xu

The distance of the centroid of this block (the point of application of C2) from the top most compression fibre = (9/14)xu

Taking moments of the forces C1 and C2 about the top most compression fibre, we get:

Eq.3.5





Where

Eq.3.6

Cu = C1 + C2 , the resultant compressive force, and, 

x3 is the point of application of Cu from the top most compression fibre.

Substituting 3.3 and 3.4 in 3.6 we get

Cu = 0.447fck b (3/7)xu + 0.447fck b (8/21)xu

⇒ Cu  = 0.447fck b (17/21)xu

⇒ Eq.3.7

Cu  = 0.362 fck b xu

It may be noted that the above eq.3.7 is given in another form in the assumption c of cl.38.1 co the code. There, the area of the stress block is given as 0.362 fck xu . Multiplying this area by b, we get the volume, which is same as eq.3.7

Now we will derive an expression for x3:

Substituting 3.3, 3.4 and 3.7 in 3.5 we get:

0.447fckb(3/7)xu(3/14)xu+ 0.447fckb(8/21)xu(9/14)xu  = 0.447fck b (8/21)xu x3

⇒ 0.447fck b (99/21x14)x2u  = 0.447fck b (17/21)xu x3

⇒ (99/14)xu  = 17 x3

⇒ Eq.3.8

x3  = (99/238)xu  = 0.416xu

This is the same expression for 'depth of center of compressive force from the extreme fibre in compression' in assumption c of the code.

So we will get the lever arm z as:

z = d - 0.416xu 

Thus we derived all the expressions required for the calculations of the quantities above the NA. Fig.3.12 below shows these details:

Fig.3.12
Complete details of stress block above NA


Forces, and the point of application of these forces in the concrete stress block above the neutral axis



Stress-Strain curve for steel

Note that the quantity xu (the depth of NA) is still an unknown. We have not derived an expression for it yet. We will now discuss about the steel. We want to know how the steel will be behaving at the point of impending failure. While we discuss about it, we will get the expression for xu also.

We want the stress in steel. We must calculate it using the graph in fig.23 of the code. So let us first discuss about fig.23. Fig.23A gives the stress strain curve for cold worked bars like Fe415 and Fe500. And Fig.23B gives the stress strain curve for mild steel like Fe250.

These graphs are plotted by conducting tension tests on steel. Strains are plotted along the X-axis, and stresses are plotted along the Y-axis. For mild steel, there is a definite yield point. That is., there is a particular stress after which the steel will begin to yield. So after this point the steel will continue to elongate at constant stress. Thus the graph after this point will be horizontal. The stress at the yield point is taken as the characteristic strength fy of steel. We have to apply the partial safety factor to this characteristic value to get the 'design value'. So we divide fy by 1.15 giving fy/1.15 = 0.87fy. The lower curve is obtained by dividing all the values by 1.15, and so, it is the design curve. If we know the strain in steel, we can calculate the design value of stress in that steel by using the design curve.

As we did in the case of concrete, we can now note down the effect of reducing the stress in steel from fy to 0.87fy: In an analysis problem, the steel is considered to have yielded if the stress in it is 0.87fy. If it was fy instead of 0.87fy, we can expect the steel to take more load before it yields.  

In a design problem, we can apply only that load which cause a stress of 0.87fy. If it was fy instead of 0.87fy, we can apply a greater load. But that is not the case. We must consider only 0.87fy.  

For cold worked bars, there is no definite yield point. That is., there is no particular stress after which the steel will elongate at constant stress. So the change from the inclined graph to the horizontal graph do not take place at a particular point. Instead, the change takes place gradually through some distance. Because of this, it is not easy to point out a particular value as the characteristic strength. So we follow the procedure given by the code to obtain the characteristic strength from the graph.

The code specifies that the 'stress corresponding to 0.002 strain offset' should be taken as the characteristic strength fy. This can be explained as follows: Consider a tensile test being conducted on a steel specimen. When the applied stress increases, the strain also increases. We plot the strain along the X axis and the stress along the Y axis. Initially this graph is a straight line. The slope of this line = Stress/Strain = Es, the modulus of elasticity of steel. But as the stress increases, it will begin to take a curved shape. With further increase of stress, the graph will become horizontal. After becoming horizontal, it will continue to elongate at constant stress. So when we reach the horizontal portion, we can be sure that the yielding have begun. But, because of the curved region between the inclined and horizontal graphs, we cannot find a particular value of stress at which the yielding began.

To solve this, we make use of a special property of steel: The property of 'giving a residual strain after yielding'. That is., while doing the tension test, if we release the load while in the initial inclined region, the steel will contract back to it's original length. This is because, the initial inclined region is the 'elastic' region. But after yielding, if the load is released, the steel will not attain it's original length. There will be a residual strain. So it follows that, if we release the load at a particular value of stress, and if on release, a residual strain is obtained, we can be sure that the steel has yielded. But still, we do not know the particular value of stress upon the release of which, the steel will begin to give residual strains. Also, the residual strain can be any value. It can be 0.001, 0.002, 0.0025, or any similar value. Whatever be the value, if there is a residual strain, we can be sure that yielding has begun. In order that all of us use a same standard value, the code specifies the required value of residual strain as 0.002. So we want the 'value of the stress', upon the release of which, the steel will give a residual strain of 0.002.

This can be easily determined from the stress strain curve of steel. We continue the test as usual. There is no need for unloading at any point. After plotting the graph, we draw a line parallel to the initial inclined line. And this parallel line should pass through the 0.002 point on the X-axis. The point of intersection of this line with the orginal graph gives the 'characteristic yield strength' fy of steel. As usual, we divide all the stress values by the partial safety factor 1.15, to get the design curve. The point of intersection of the parallel line with the design curve will give the 'design yield strength' of steel.

For analysis and design purposes, we can use the graph in fig.23A of the code. We will try to plot a design curve on our own. While trying to plot it, we will understand it's salient features. Let us plot the design curve for Fe415 steel.

We know that the initial inclined portion and the final horizontal portions are straight lines. So they can be easily plotted. For the inclined line, any two points on it is sufficient, and for the horizontal portion, any one point on it is sufficient. The curved portion is the difficult part. It requires more points. The fig.23A gives us these points. We can see a dashed line parallel to the initial inclined line, starting from 0.002 on the X axis. It meets the characteristic curve at a certain point. A horizontal dashed line is drawn from this meeting point towards the left up to the Y axis. At the point of intersection of the horizontal dashed line and the Y axis is marked: 'fy'. This means that the 'y coordinate of the point of intersection' of the inclined dashed line with the characteristic curve is fy. (It will indeed be fy, the characteristic yield strength, because 0.002 is the 'proof strain' as discussed earlier). So the y coordinate of the corresponding point on the design curve will be equal to fy/1.15 = 415/1.15 = 360.9 N/mm2. Now we want the x coordinate. For this we will use the fig.3.13 given below:

Fig.3.13
Last point of the curved portion


stress strain curve for steel


In the fig., the initial inclined line is drawn in red colour, the final horizontal line is drawn in magenta colour, and the intermdiate curve is drawn in blue colour. A triangle PQR is drawn. PR corresponds to the inclined dashed line in the code, drawn from the strain value of 0.002. So we can see that the x coordinate will be equal to 0.002 + PQ. Thus our next step is to calculate PQ.

In the ΔPQR, tan∠RPQ = RQ⁄PQ  
⇒ PQ = RQ⁄tan∠RPQ    

But tan∠RPQ is the slope of PR. So it is also the slope of the initial inclined line of the design curve. 

But the slope of this initial inclined line = 
Stress⁄Strain   = Elastic modulus of steel = Es = 2 x 105 N/mm2.

We know that RQ = the y coordinate of the point R, which we already calculated as 360.9 

Thus we get PQ = 360.9⁄200000 = 0.0018045

So the x coordinate of point R = 0.002 + 0.0018045 = 0.0038045 = 0.00380

Thus the coordinates of the last point of the curved portion are (0.00380,360.9)

This is for Fe415 steel. For the general case, for the last point of the curved portion, we can write the following:

Eq.3.9

x coordinate = 0.002 + [fy/ 1.15 x 200000] = 0.002 + fy/230000

y coordinate = fy/ 1.15

The above discussion was based on fig.3.13 above. It is a complete fig. with all the required points of the design curve of Fe415 steel. Such a complete fig. is used for discussion purpose only. Based on that discussion, we have derived the general form in Eq.3.9. So, on a new empty graph paper, with only the axes drawn to proper scale, we can directly mark the last point of the curved portion using Eq.3.9. This is shown in the animation below:


method of plotting the design stress strain curve of steel in limit state design

This is also the first point of the final horizontal portion. As the portion is horizontal, it requires only one point to plot. So with this just one point, the calculations related to the final horizontal line is complete.

Now we will calculate the second last point of the curved portion. We will do this in the next section.


PREVIOUS

NEXT

           
            Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com- All Rights Reserved


Chapter 3 (cont..1) Compressive force contributed by rectangular portion

In the previous section we saw the shape of the concrete stress block. In this section, we will discuss the compressive force produced by this block. The fig.3.4 below shows the elevation view of the beam with the stress block attached to it. 

Fig.3.4
Elevation view showing the Stress block attached to the beam



The origin of the stress graph of concrete is at the neutral axis of the beam section


At the first glance, we might get the impression that the stresses are plotted on the X-axis, and distances along the beam section are plotted on the Y-axis. But this is not true. The graph given by the code is a Stress-Strain curve. Not a Stress-Distance curve. So we need a method to represent strain in terms of the distance. This can be made more clear using the following fig.3.5:

Fig.3.5
Relation between strain and distance


Distance and strain are plotted to the same scale on the beam section



In the above fig., we can see that the strain is plotted as equal to the vertical distance, even though they are two different quantities. This is made possible by selecting a suitable scale for plotting the strain along the vertical axis. For selecting the scale, we make use of the 'manner in which the strain variation occurs in a beam section'. So we will have a brief discussion about this variation:

A beam will consist of numerous planes which are perpendicular to the axis of the beam. We need to know about the behaviour of these planes When the bending of the beam occurs. The X-ray views in fig.3.6 below shows some of the planes inside the beam.

Fig.3.6
View of some planes inside the beam


planes which are normal to the axis of bending will remain plane after bending


When the beam bends, our first impression would be that, the planes will bend into curved shapes as shown in fig.3.6(b). If a plane bend into a curved shape, it can no longer be called a 'plane' because, such a curved surface will have 3 dimensions. But a real plane have only 2 dimensions: length and width. It has no thickness, height, or curvature. In our case, all the plane sections which are perpendicular to the axis of bending, remain plane even after bending. This is shown in fig.3.6(c). An elevation view of the beam after bending is shown in the fig.3.7 below:

Fig.3.7
Elevation view of the planes after bending



Elevation view showing the planes normal to the axis of bending remaining plane after bending


This property of the beam makes our calculations a lot more easier. It may be noted that this property does not change even at very high stresses, when the beam section is at the point of impending failure. The fig.3.8 below shows the end of a section coloured in red. AB is the original edge, and PQ is the new edge. PQ is a straight line because, AB will remain plane even after bending.

Fig.3.8
End portion of a segment



change in length of any fibre is proportional to the distance of that fibre from the neutral axis




We can see that the change in length Δ l of any fibre is proportional to the distance of the fibre from the NA. If Δ l is proportional to the distance, the strain (strain = Δ l / l ) will also be proportional to the distance. This proportionality would not be true if PQ is a curve. Also it is a direct proportion. That is., when distance increases, strain also increases and vice versa. So we can represent it using the equation: Strain = A constant x distance. Thus while plotting the graph, we can select a scale for the Y-axis in such a way that the strain and distance will be the same. 

Thus we see that the stress block of concrete can be attached to the beam section as shown in the fig.3.4 above. In fact, we do not have to plot this stress block along the beam section. We only need to understand the 'variation of stress' (ie., the stress at various points) along the section. The above discussion was to make clear how the 'stress-strain curve' given in the code appear like a 'stress-distance' curve in the fig.3.4.

Also, from the above discussion, we see that strain is directly proportional to distance. So the strain diagram will be a straight line.  

We can now proceed to calculate the area enclosed by the graph. That is., the total area of blue portion and red portion in fig.3.4. The fig.3.2 and 3.3 that we saw in the previous section are for fck =20 N/mm2. We will derive the area for the general purpose where fck can take any value.


We must find the areas of the rectangular portion and parabolic portion separately. We know the length of the rectangular portion. It is equal to 0.447fck . But we do not know the height. To find the height, we make use of the same 'variation of strains' in the beam that we discussed above.

We have seen that Strain = A constant x distance. So we can represent the variation of strain with distance by a straight line. Also, if we know the distance of any fibre from the NA, we can easily calculate the strain in that fibre. We will use this property in reverse to find the height of our rectangle. That is., we know the strain at the beginning of the rectangular portion. We want to find out the distance at which this strain occurs. For this, we use the fig.3.9 below:

Fig.3.9
Distance at which the strain of 0.002 occur



strain distribution can be represented by a straight line



In the fig., PQ is a straight line and it represents the strain across the section. We have two triangles above the NA.
• Base of the larger triangle = 0.0035. 
• Base of the smaller triangle = 0.002. 
• Altitude of the larger triangle = xu. 
• Altitude of the smaller triangle = x2. 
So we have
0.0035/0.002 = x
u/x2. 
⇒ x2 = (2/3.5) xu. 
x1 = xu –  x2 = xu – (2/3.5) xu 
⇒
Eq.3.2
x1 = (3/7)xu

Thus we get the height of the rectangular portion. We can add this information to the fig.3.9 and get the modified fig.3.10 as shown below:

Fig.3.10
Ht. of rectangular portion in relation to the strain diagram



height of the rectangular portion can be obtained from the strain diagram



Knowing the length and height, we can find the area of the rectangular portion, which is equal to 0.447fck(3/7)xu. This area multiplied by the width 'b' of the section will give the volume of the rectangular stress block. This volume is the compressive force C1 contributed by the rectangular portion. So we get

C1 = 0.447fckb(3/7)xu 

This force acts at the centroid of the rectangular block. The centroid will be at a distance of  x1/2 from the top surface of the beam. 


Substituting for x1 from 3.2, we can write:
The point of application of C1 from the top most compression fibre = (3/14)xu


So now we have all the details about the rectangular portion. These details are shown in the fig.3.11 below:

Fig.3.11
Forces and distances related to the rectangular portion



Force contributed by the rectangular portion of the concrete stress block



In the above figs.3.10 and 3.11, a quantity εst is shown in the strains diagram. This is the strain in the reinforcing steel. The yellow arrow represents the stress in the steel. We will learn about them when we take up the discussion on steel. In our present discussion, these two quantities do not come in any calculations.

In the next section we will discuss about the parabolic portion.


                                                         
            Copyright ©2015 limitstatelessons.blogspot.com - All Rights Reserved